“I don’t know what will come next,” Associate Professor Bulent Şık told me on the phone. We spoke a day before he was sentenced to five to 12 years in prison in his final court hearing.
As one of the rare, brave scientists working with critical data on health safety in Turkey, Şık has been under increasing pressure. First he lost his job, then the government opened a criminal case against him. On September 26, he was sentenced to 15 months in prison.
How did the situation get to this point?
Associate Professor Şık was the deputy director of the Food Safety and Agricultural Research Center at Akdeniz University, based in Antalya. In 2011, the Ministry of Health decided to conduct research in conjunction with the university to examine the correlation between toxic residue and the increasing cancer rate in five cities. Şık contributed to the study and analyzed thousands of food and water samples.
The research took four years, and the results were more frightening than expected. Şık asked Ministry officials when they would take action based on the results, but they answered, “We’ll see.”
They did eventually act, but in an unexpected way. In 2015, Şık, along with more than 2,000 academics, signed the Academics for Peace petition. Soon after, he was removed from his position as director and from his research projects. After the coup attempt in July 2016, he was expelled from the university system as a part of a government decree. So far, 6,081 academics have been expelled in total. In total, 549 Peace Academicians were removed and banned from public service with decree laws, dismissed, forced to resign or retire. 789 academicians were tried for signing the petition, four were arrested, hundreds got fined and their passports were confiscated.
Is publishing “the poison list” a crime?
Şık lost his academic title and job, and his brother, the prominent journalist and HDP MP Ahmet Şık, was imprisoned.
Yet Şık’s mind was on the data sitting in his computer. He continued to ask local officials if they had been informed about the research and whether any precautions had been taken. A CHP MP raised the question in the Parliament to no effect.
In 2018, Şık came to the conclusion that nothing would be done on the part of the government, and he started to work to make his own data public.
On April 15, 2018, the newspaper Cumhuriyet published a series of articles under the headline “The state has concealed which products are carcinogenic—we are making them public! Here is the poison list.”
According to the findings, drinking water in the northern part of the Thrace region and Kocaeli, a city 80 kilometers from Istanbul, contained high levels of carcinogenic elements such as aluminium, arsenic, and lead. Şık also studied pesticides in agricultural products and found that 17% contained above-average levels of dangerous chemicals that are especially harmful to children and infants.
After the series was published in Cumhuriyet, the Ministry of Health filed a court case against Şık, alleging that he illegally shared the findings of the project conducted by the Ministry of Health.
Şık: They don’t tackle cancer, they tackle me!
The series sparked limited public attention because the mainstream media did not report on the study and the health risks. The way the pro-government, mainstream media covered the case says it all:
“HDP MP Ahmet Şık’s brother Bülent Şık took part in the Ministry of Health research on carcinogens. After he was fired, he leaked data without the permission of the government. Thus, he received a prison sentence of 1 year and 3 months.” (Sabah Daily, 26.9.2019)
In an interview with Gazete Duvar, Şık said, “The research contains critical information about where and why there is heavy pollution. For the first time, we have data on which chemical compounds are polluting specific areas. And we also know why some cancer forms are on the rise. This means that the polluters can be found. But I think the Ministry does not want to bother them. They don’t tackle cancer, they tackle me!”
Şık’s final hearing was monitored by lawyers, human rights defenders and professional organizations. He has been sentenced to 1 year and 3 months in prison on the charge of “disclosing information about one’s duties” while he has been acquitted of “procuring prohibited information.” Now, his lawyers will appeal the verdict, which will either reverse or uphold the prison sentence.
When I asked Şık if he felt any regrets, he answered promptly: “If you conduct a research which implies millions of people can be affected with cancer, you can’t simply act as if nothing is wrong and hide it. Governments might do that, but an academic can’t. Personally, I will not give up my quest to pursue the truth. We need to rivive the public sphere in order to remind the government not to act like conglomerates but do their jobs. Which is to protect public health.”
Amnesty International underlines the fact that Şık is a whistleblower and his actions are protected under the right of freedom of expression which includes the right to freely disseminate and receive information.
One should keep in mind that the European Council formally adopted new rules on whistle blower protection. New rules provide a high level of protection to whistle blowers against retaliation.
Some medical experts in Turkey argue that the hospitals which were previously emptied by the AKP government, can easily be ransformed into functioning hospitals with minimal spending to treat COVID-19 patients. One might wonder why they were closed in the first place.
Turkey has one of the world’s fastest growing coronavirus outbreaks, confirmed cases double every three days. The statistics, combined with the capacity of the health system and nature of the restrictions raise great concerns. Doctors are forced to apologize for their critical remarks, health workers are banned from making press releases on their conditions. Aside […]
The last time President Erdoğan, who is 66 years-old, physically took part in a meeting was a week ago. Nobody asks whether the President and his close circle have been tested for coronavirus. And of course, no one dares to ask what happens if he gets sick, and what the Turkish Presidential System would bring.
The Covid-19 will inevitably affect a much wider population, and Turkey’s limited testing is dramatic. Scientists, doctors unanimously urge for a radical testing procedure. In Istanbul, a city of 16 million, there are only four hospitals conducting tests. Meanwhile, states of emergency, strict restrictions and bans are anything but new in Turkey!
As he traveled back to Turkey from Azerbaijan, Erdoğan ominously announced a new wave of repression. A few days later, Osman Kavala was re-arrested, the mayor of Diyarbakır Selçuk Mızraklı was sentenced to more than 9 years in jail and 7 journalists were arrested.
Again we see them on the news, migrants flocking to the borders and the human traffickers going about their “business” in front of the cameras. As thousands of migrants seek to cross the border from Turkey to Greece and Bulgaria- some getting injured and dying whilst doing so - authorities talk of them as if they are cheap tokens. Not only in Turkey but in the EU countries as well.
The pro-governmental media in Turkey, which usually targets well-known individuals or critics, targets ordinary people as well. But what’s perhaps more worth talking about is how the life of the poor living in cities has changed — and how they are perceived. They, too, want to live a good life. Or just to be a part of it, even for a few seconds. And they, too, want to show off.
Just as Kavala was preparing for his release after 840 days spent in the Silivri Prison, the prosecutor’s office announced the philanthropist would be questioned on “attempting to overthrow the constitutional order." This proves how partial, arbitrary and politically involved the Turkish judiciary is. Yet the dynamics of this process remain unclear.
It’s hard to voice opposition to war when the coffins of slain soldiers are being sent back from Syria and when the nationalist mood is in full swing. However HDP deputy and former journalist Ahmet Şık, who has been jailed twice and is still tried on the Cumhuriyet case, says that they have the responsibility to question why so many young people are dying for.
The watchmen will not operate under a specific law or the constitution but under the government’s direct orders. Opposition parties thus warn of a “parallel police force” that enjoys unprecedented powers. At night, the watchmen could well turn into the state’s moral police.
Although the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled for his immediate release on Dec. 10, 2019, Osman Kavala remains as the only defendant under detention at the Gezi trial. So the question is whether the Council of Europe (CoE) and member states will stand up. If they will not do that, what is the function of the ECHR and why should other states bother to follow its rules?
Well-known economists have questioned how Kanal Istanbul will be financed, but they haven’t yet received any answers. Prof. Dr. Haluk Levent from Bilgi University believes that Kanal Istanbul is a Ponzi scheme, but with a difference: in a Ponzi Scheme, everything must be on the record, but this is not the case for Kanal Istanbul. The scheme is changing the town planning and zoning.
The media almost totally neglects or misinterprets cases related to July 15 in fear of being targeted themselves. On the other hand, high-ranking Gülenists, who have long fled the country, are in fact using the cases and prison sentences for their own PR.
Despite the government's pledge to combat femicide and domestic abuse, 474 women were murdered by men in 2019 in Turkey. Women’s rights advocates have repeatedly said the system is too weak to protect women.
Data from the last two years in Turkey points to a steady decrease in almost every aspect of a functioning, healthy democracy, such as freedom of speech, quality of education, gender and income equality, and the rule of law. It’s no surprise that society has become unhappier compared to 2017. Surely the AKP-MHP alliance is responsible for this great social, economic and political collapse.
Two days ago I went to the forth hearing of the Gezi trial in Silivri, where Kavala is the only imprisoned suspect among 16 civil society activists accused with ‘organizing and financing Gezi protests to overthrow the AKP government’ back in 2013. These trials are top examples of how rule of law is undermined and how human rights abuses are executed.
Kanal Istanbul is not only critical for Erdoğan financially. It also represents a political battlefield in which he wishes to beat his opponents, in this case the new opposition Istanbul Metropolitan Mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu.
General elections appear to be on the agenda in 2023. That is what statements from President Erdoğan and his alliance partner, the MHP leader Bahçeli, suggest. Yet, the prospect of snap elections also looms. Many politicians, economists and journalists claim snap elections will be held in 2020. While snap elections may not seem logical, logics don’t apply to Turkish politics.
The severe violations of sick prisoners rights are against the law and contradict with international agreements Turkey partakes in. Human right advocates accuse the government of being unwilling to address these problems and point to the The European Council, which remains silent.
Just a few hours before police teargassed women in the streets of Istanbul, Emine Erdoğan, wife of President Tayyip Erdoğan, was giving a speech that denounced violence against women on the occasion of the International Day for Eliminating Violence against Women. However, Mrs. Erdoğan has also stated that the rise in violence against women is just a perception and that today, thanks to the AKP, women can ask for their rights.
As a journalist, I find it to be embarrassing and paradoxical that President Trump, not known to be a supporter of the free press, mocked the Turkish press.
Yet his words, “You sure you’re a reporter? You don’t work for Turkey with that question?” reflect the truth regarding the group of people Erdoğan took along with him to Washington. These words sum up the status of the Turkish mainstream media.
Turkey generally does not rank high in suicide rates. One reason is religion; in Islam suicide is a sin. Culture and family ties also are among strong reasons why people refrain from taking their lives according to experts. However figures show that there is a rise in suicide rates in Turkey. The society does not only suffer from economical crisis and neo-liberalism, but also a harsh transformation from a hybrid democracy to a more authoritarian state.
Last week, another bunch of journalists were sacked from daily Hürriyet newspaper, which is still considered as the “flagship” of the mainstream media. In fact, Hürriyet lost its prestige long while ago. It doesn’t really matter who the editor in chief is now. Or why and how journalists were sacked. It is the final nail in the coffin. The mainstream media resembles the living death.
By looking at mainstream media, military salutes of popular figures or twitter trending topics, one might assume that Turkish people were heavily supporting the military operation in Northern Syria -officially called “Operation Peace Spring” ending in 8 days- no matter what the rest of the world says. When there is any military action in Turkey or outside its borders, it becomes even harder for critical voices to be heard.