Duvar English – Reuters

Turkey and the United States are in a fresh row over Washington’s call to release businessman, philanthropist and human rights activist Osman Kavala.

U.S. State Department Principal Deputy Spokesperson Cale Brown called for the release of Kavala, who on July 27 marked his 1,000th day in prison without a conviction and despite an acquittal from a previous case, given he has not been convicted.

“We call upon Turkey to comply with its own commitment to justice and rule of law and to release Osman Kavala from detention, while pursuing a just, transparent, and speedy resolution to his case,” Brown said in a statement late on July 27.

A day later, Turkey’s Foreign Ministry said the U.S. statement did not respect the principles of a state based on the rule of law.

“Everyone needs to respect this process that is being carried out by independent courts,” the ministry spokesman said in a statement.

“No state or person can give orders to Turkish courts regarding judicial processes.”

Kavala has been in jail since November 2017. He was initially accused of financing nationwide protests in 2013, but he was acquitted on those charges in February and was ordered to be released.

Hours after the acquittal, however, he was ordered to be detained for another case related to the July 15, 2016 failed coup attempt and later formally arrested again. The charge on the same case was changed in March to espionage but an indictment has not been prepared.

Kavala denies all charges.

‘We are pushing for real justice in Turkey’

Nacho Sanchez Amor, the European Parliament’s Turkey rapporteur, said Kavala had become a test for Turkey’s sincerity with regards to human rights.

“We are pushing and pushing again for real justice in Turkey,” he said.

Critics say the independence of Turkey’s judiciary from politics has been severely eroded in recent years. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) say the judiciary makes its decisions independently.

In a statement marking his 1,000 days in detention, Kavala said: “A parallel law enforcement system has been set in motion, which enables to keep in prison the persons who ‘needed’ to be punished, regardless of the established facts and concrete information about their activities.”

The European Court of Human Rights has also called for Kavala’s release due to insufficient evidence related to both the abortive 2016 coup and 2013 protests.